I don't know if you'll remember me, but almost two years ago you catered our daughter's wedding in our home in
Salisbury, PA.  For two reasons I had to write you and thank you again.  First, everyday I see pictures of the food and cake you prepared for the reception on our screen saver slide show which goes through all our pictures.  I was a little distracted that day in February '07 and didn't even get to taste everything, so seeing the pictures is a treat for me.  I still wish I could have had some of the brie in pastry!  Yum!  Everyone said it was so delicious.   Second, I recently went to a winter wedding and was so unimpressed with their cake.  The snowflake cake you made for us was absolutely the most beautiful wedding cake I've seen.  "Ace of Cakes" has nothing on you!  I hope you took pictures of it.  It was impressive.  So, thank you again.  I want you to know how much I appreciated your incredible work, and still am thrilled with what you did for us.   Best wishes for 2009! Sincerely, Kathy V.
Dear Baxters,
Jon and I would like to thank you for doing such a wonderful job at our wedding! The guests loved the meal and there wasn't a slice of cake left over! It was all very delicious! We hope to visit Cumberland on our 1st Anniversay and would like to order a small cake. So we will contact you next year. Thank you so much again, Jon & Kathy R
Dear Susan, Thank you for the wonderful advice and help you gave me planning my "Alice" tea party. The food was almost too beautiful to eat! Tracy

Dear Susan & John, Thank you for the first birthday cake it was a true work of art! Joe & Aarti S

Susan, Thank you so much for creating the perfect wedding cake for us! We got so many compliments on how delicious it was! Truly Clayton & Steph
Dear Susan, We wanted to thank you for making the cake for our daughter's baptism! The cake was both beautiful and delicious. The time and effort you spent making such a wonderful cake made a blessed day even more special! Sincerely Heather & Aaron
Dear Susan and John, Thank you for the beautiful and delicious cake. Everyone raved about it! Take care, Becky

Dear Susan & John, Thank you again for a job well done!!! Erika C

Susan, Thanks so much for an awesome lunch, you guys do a great job! Sincerely, Jackie A.

Dear Susan, Thank you so much for the beautiful and delicious work! Sincerely, Shannon M.

Dear John & Susan, I am just now beginning to come down from the euphoria of yesterday's festivites. Everything went exactly according to plan so I am extremely pleased. Thank you for your major contribution to the festivites. The food was absolutely lovely and delicious and I know Gloria was pleased also. It was a pleasure to work with you and you certainly know the right amount of food according to the numbers. Thank you for everything. Gratefully, Carol D.

Dear Baxter's Catering, Thank you for the deliicious meal you served at Dr. C's office. I will definately use your services for future engagements. Thank you, Kelley C.

Susan, Thank you so much for all your help and the delicious food. Everyone was very complementary. It was all very good and we enjoyed it. Thanks again, Karen H.

Dear Baxter's, Everything was delicious and received rave reviews! Thank you for everything. I hope we will be able to use your services again in the near future. Sincerely, Julie R.

Dear Baxters: Just wanted to let you know how much we enjoyed the dinner. The servings were a good size - it was so easy to handle and really good. Most of the carry - in things I have tried have been rather huge globs which I have reworked. The scallops were excellent - the way I like them without a lot of coating or liquid - the sauce was very nice. The wine deserves a special comment, too. It was one of the better ones I have had and a new brand to us. Thanks again for your helpful service - I think it should be advertised and we certainly will recommend it. Cordially, Maxine F.

Dear Susan and John, The wedding cake was lovely - but more importantly it was delish! Everyone loved it and as I told you people at the wedding actually "ate wedding cake". Thank you for helping make it such a special day for Ginniann and Ed. Fondly, Patty

Dear Mr. & Mrs. Baxter, We all very much enjoyed the delicious meal you provided last night. It really made the occasion great. I haven't had a tastier meal in years. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Michael L.

Dear Baxters, Thank you for the mot delicious chocolate cake. All my guests we impressed - I gav you the credit. I'll nver bake again!! Marie S.
Susan, I just wanted to personally thank you for the gorgeous, delicious delicacies that you prepared for the auction. I know how much time such a task consumes. Everyone loved them; they were again truly a huge success. Thank you again, Bobbie

To Baxter's: Thank you for your creativity!!! The fire engine was beautiful. Quite a hit with 3 year old boys! Great Job! Thanks again for making a special treat for the birthday party. Tracy, Dan & Sean

Susan & John, Thanks for the wonderful additions to my party! Joyce

Susan, I'd like to thank you so very much for everything you and your staff did for us on our wedding day. The food was wonderful! The hors d'oeuvres were perfect and our dinner meal was absolutely superb! I absolutely Loved the wedding cake, and I know many guests had seconds -on the cake and the meal! Susan - I appreciate all of the time you spent with me in helping me to plan all of the details for the day and I couldn't have asked for anything more! We had the best day! All the best to you and your staff! With many thanks, Michelle & Doug

John & Susan: Thank you both again for the absolutely delicious food you prepared for our wedding. The presentation was beautiful and everyone loved it. A special thank you for the torte which was out of this world! Larry & Debbie V.

Susan, Thanks so much. As usual, the cake was a big hit! It was the only dessert Nicky wanted- she took what was left home with her!! Hope you and John have a wonderful- and profitable- holiday season. Leslie
Susan & John, I just wanted to say thank you for everything! It was wonderful and everyone enjoyed all of your dishes. If ever I need another catering event, I'll be sure to call you! Thanks again, you both did a fantastic job. Astrid & Family

Baxters: Just wanted you to know how much everyone enjoyed everything you prepared. The grilled chicken salad was really delicious and my husband said the chicken salad sandwich was the best ever. The cakes were awesome also. Thanks so much. Penny
Thank you so much for the superb job you did on the baby shower cake. It was exactly like the picture from your website. Everyone wanted to get a picture of it before it was cut. It was one of the most adorable cakes I have ever seen. It will make such a nice memory for the expecting mom's photo album. You are very talented. Janice
John & Susan, Thank you again for everything it was perfect! Nick
Susan, We just wanted to say thank you so much for the wonderful 1st anniversary cake you baked for us! It was delicious & absolutely beautiful!! We so appreciated you doing it & being so accommodating  with us picking it up late in the evening. You truly helped make our wedding day AND 1st anniversary special!! Thanks again, Laura & Matt
Dear Susan, Thank you so much for all that you've done to make today a celebration of my Aunt Janet's life. Your willingness to work with me long distance, to make last minute changes and to accommodate this lunch despite another event has been a gift to us all. You also shared that you do all this as you too, grieve a loved one. God gives us our strength but the hole they leave in our daily lives still just hurts. God bless you for all that you've done to make today a wonderful day.Your caring and kindness has been very appreciated. Kelly
We just wanted to take the time to thank you for providing such great food for our Dec wedding. We had several compliments on how delicious all of the food was and how beautiful and tasty  the cake was. Our expectations were definitely met and we appreciate all of your hard work. Have a great Christmas with your family and hopefully we will be needing your services again soon. God Bless,  Brandon & Heather
Susan & John, Kyle and I cannot Thank you enough for all of your hard work. Everyone said the food was out of this world! Annie & Kyle
Just a few pictures I wanted to send you. Thank you for helping make my Christmas ornament party a huge success. The food and your service was flawless. Thanks again Marlee
Customer Reviews

About Us
Customer Reviews
Contact Us
Cocktail Food
Event Gallery
Specialty Cakes
Free Brochure
  Suzie, John & Will,   Just wanted to say again that everything was perfect! Rave reviews on your food. I really
  appreciate all that you did to help make Mary Caite'  day special. You have no idea how much it means to us!
 Thanks again,   Wendy & Chris
Susan and John, what a GREAT party you guys put on this past weekend; I am so thankful that Mary Kay, Paul, Mark and I were able to attend as well. The room was perfect and the food was awesome!!   Chuck
Dear Baxter's Catering, Thank you so much for the fine food at our wedding. The meals were delicious and the staff was professional. We appreciate all the ways that you worked with us for this special day. Sincerely Amy & Frank
Dear Susan & John, When I got home Wednesday and set up the food, I was more than pleased. You did an excellent job and everything was delicious. Thanks so much for helping me with the celebration of Mother's 90th birthday. Sincerely, Elaine B
Dear Susan, Thank you again for the wonderful catering you provided for our daughter's baby shower brunch. The food was spectacular, and I received many compliments on it. I do appreciate your expertise and guidance throughout the planning. I would recommend you in a heartbeat & hope to have an occasion to call on you again. Thanks so much for everything! Carolyn B.
Dear Susan, You were a wonderful blessing to our family during our heartbreaking grief. We shall never forget your kindness as you lovingly prepared and delivered my Mother's favorite Chicken Pot Pie for the funeral luncheon. Those attending shared that it was very delectable and the very best it could be on a snowy winter day to comfort our heartbroken souls. Thank you helping us on short notice. Cumberland is indeed blessed to have you. Anne L. 
Susan, Thanks to you, your Husband, and staff for making our day so special. We loved the food and the service was amazing. We will definitely recommend you to others.
Susan, It has been such a pleasure working with you. We really appreciate how much effort you put into making sure our wedding dinner was a delicious treat! If we ever come back Cumberland way to host an event, you can be sure we'll be giving you a call !!!  DW & Em  they also posted this review on Yelp:
Baxter's Gourmet catered our wedding at Rocky Gap State Park, and we couldn't be happier! Susan was always responsive when we had questions, she worked with us to figure out a menu that would fit in our budget and fill all our guests, and it did that, and it was Delicious besides. Simply fantastic food. If you are looking for a caterer who will go the extra mile to make your event a success, you just found them.
Dear Susan, We want to thank you and the MR. for the lovely food that you served us at Rocky Gap State Park today.  Everyone was very pleased with the delicious dishes as well as us,  Ray and Pam.  It added to make it our special day. And to know you and Tab and Brenda were in the class together at Allegany High.  I will be an advertisement for your business. Sincerely, Ray and Pam

We treasure all the personal thanks you notes we have received over the years. We feel blessed to have made so many new friends. We hope to continue for another 24 years!